| Saturday, March 3, 2012 |
| REVOLUTION UNITED REVOLUTION 99S | 7 | | MANHATTAN SUNDERLAND | 0 |
| NY ELITE FC NEW YORK ELITE FC RSL | 1 | | HOWELL UNITED SC BHOYS | 0 |
| Sunday, March 4, 2012 |
| REVOLUTION UNITED REVOLUTION 99S | 1 | | HOWELL UNITED SC BHOYS | 0 |
| NY ELITE FC NEW YORK ELITE FC RSL | 5 | | MANHATTAN SUNDERLAND | 0 |
| REVOLUTION UNITED REVOLUTION 99S | 2 | | NY ELITE FC NEW YORK ELITE FC RSL | 0 |
| MANHATTAN SUNDERLAND | 0 | | HOWELL UNITED SC BHOYS | 2 |
| |