| Saturday, March 3, 2012 |
| CLARKSTOWN 02 WHITE | 3 | | EAST BRUNSWICK SC EB GREEN DEVILS | 1 |
| STATEN ISLAND UNITED LIGHTNING | 0 | | SABA/METOVAL BROOKLYN CITY | 0 |
| HBC BARRACUDAS | 2 | | EAST BRUNSWICK SC EB GREEN DEVILS | 0 |
| STATEN ISLAND UNITED LIGHTNING | 0 | | CLARKSTOWN 02 WHITE | 0 |
| SABA/METOVAL BROOKLYN CITY | 5 | | EAST BRUNSWICK SC EB GREEN DEVILS | 0 |
| STATEN ISLAND UNITED LIGHTNING | 0 | | HBC BARRACUDAS | 4 |
| CLARKSTOWN 02 WHITE | 3 | | SABA/METOVAL BROOKLYN CITY | 2 |
| STATEN ISLAND UNITED LIGHTNING | 1 | | EAST BRUNSWICK SC EB GREEN DEVILS | 1 |
| SABA/METOVAL BROOKLYN CITY | 0 | | HBC BARRACUDAS | 0 |
| CLARKSTOWN 02 WHITE | 1 | | HBC BARRACUDAS | 2 |
| |