| Saturday, March 3, 2012 |
| FC COPA AVENTURA | 1 | | COMMACK SOCCER ELITE | 1 |
| NORTHPORT COW HARBOR UNITED SC STRIKERS | 1 | | SPIRIT UNITED SC AZTECS | 2 |
| FC COPA AVENTURA | 0 | | MOUNT OLIVE PREMIER 95/96 | 0 |
| NORTHPORT COW HARBOR UNITED SC STRIKERS | 0 | | COMMACK SOCCER ELITE | 3 |
| FSA UNITED FC U16 GIRLS NAVY | 1 | | SPIRIT UNITED SC AZTECS | 1 |
| FSA UNITED FC U16 GIRLS NAVY | 3 | | MOUNT OLIVE PREMIER 95/96 | 0 |
| Sunday, March 4, 2012 |
| NORTHPORT COW HARBOR UNITED SC STRIKERS | 2 | | MOUNT OLIVE PREMIER 95/96 | 0 |
| FSA UNITED FC U16 GIRLS NAVY | 0 | | COMMACK SOCCER ELITE | 0 |
| FC COPA AVENTURA | 2 | | SPIRIT UNITED SC AZTECS | 0 |
| FSA UNITED FC U16 GIRLS NAVY | 1 | | COMMACK SOCCER ELITE | 0 |
| |