| Saturday, November 3, 2012 |
| TERRE HAUTE FLYERS 04B | 2 | | PENDLETON FC ARABIAN U9 ACADEMY B | 0 |
| UNITED SOCCER ALLIANCE OF INDIANA USAI '04 BOYS EAGLES NAVY | 2 | | INDIANAPOLIS RANGERS ELITE 04 | 5 |
| INDIANAPOLIS RANGERS ELITE 04 | 5 | | TERRE HAUTE FLYERS 04B | 0 |
| PENDLETON FC ARABIAN U9 ACADEMY B | 0 | | UNITED SOCCER ALLIANCE OF INDIANA USAI '04 BOYS EAGLES NAVY | 9 |
| Sunday, November 4, 2012 |
| TERRE HAUTE FLYERS 04B | 1 | | UNITED SOCCER ALLIANCE OF INDIANA USAI '04 BOYS EAGLES NAVY | 6 |
| INDIANAPOLIS RANGERS ELITE 04 | 11 | | PENDLETON FC ARABIAN U9 ACADEMY B | 0 |
| PENDLETON FC ARABIAN U9 ACADEMY B | 0 | | TERRE HAUTE FLYERS 04B | 3 |
| UNITED SOCCER ALLIANCE OF INDIANA USAI '04 BOYS EAGLES NAVY | 1 | | INDIANAPOLIS RANGERS ELITE 04 | 4 |
| |